Calorific Value of Sugarcane Bagasse: A Comparative Analysis of Mill vs. Diffuser

Introduction

Sugarcane bagasse, once considered waste, has come to be valued as an essential input for cogenerating electricity and producing steam, adding value to mills and to the sugar-energy sector. With the recent drop in value of electricity produced in condensing turbines and growing demand, driven especially by corn ethanol producers, significant price variations are emerging. However, bagasse is traded on a wet-weight basis, without considering technical parameters such as calorific value, which can lead to unfair negotiations.

In Brazilian mills, mill (roller) extraction processes predominate, although diffusers account for a significant share of the industrial base. This diversity raises the question of how each extraction process can influence the composition and calorific value of bagasse. Bagasse is expected to degrade when stored from one harvest to the next, mainly through microbiological action and exposure to the weather — rain, solar radiation and wind — acting on the piles. Although this topic is relevant, it will be addressed in a future study. In a recent analysis for one of A1’s projects, we identified significant differences between bagasse from mills and bagasse produced by diffusers. In this article, we explore how the extraction process (mill vs. diffuser) influences the composition and calorific value of bagasse, with emphasis on its impact on steam production.

 

Comparison of Mineral Impurity: Mill vs. Diffuser

Recently, in an energy efficiency project, we compared bagasse production at two units: one with a mill and the other with a diffuser. The difference in juice quality between the two extraction processes is well known: juice extracted by diffusion is of higher quality than juice extracted by milling. This is because the diffusion process acts as a filter, resulting in juice with a lower suspended solids content. According to Rein (2007), juice is extracted with 0.12 g/100 g for the diffuser and 0.67 g/100 g for the mill. For practical purposes, we will assume that the suspended solids in the juice consist of 60% mineral impurity (soil) and 40% vegetable impurity (bagacillo).

Using a simplified balance, we can find the amount of mineral impurity that remains in the bagasse for both processes. The table below shows the main parameters used in the balance and its result.

Table 1 – Parameters used to determine mineral impurity in bagasse

Mineral impurity in sugarcane

0,7%*

Juice produced by the mill

1,07 **

Juice produced by the diffuser

1,20 **

Bagasse moisture

50%*

Estimated impurity in mill bagasse

3,1 %

Estimated impurity in diffuser bagasse

1,2 %

* assumed for both processes: mill and diffuser
** kg of juice/kg of sugarcane: difference caused by the different amount of imbibition water in the two processes.

 

Methodology for Calculating the Lower Heating Value (LHV)

The LHV, or lower heating value, is the parameter representing the amount of energy released by the complete combustion of a fuel. It can be determined by calorimetry or estimated using empirical formulas based on the fuel’s elemental composition. Empirical studies show some variations in the fitted parameters, such as the Dulong formula and the Milne formula, Demirbaş (2004). These differences depend, among other factors, on the type of fuel, ash, impurities, etc. The equation below provides a good approximation for sugarcane bagasse.

where:

  • represent, respectively, the mass fractions of carbon, hydrogen, oxygen, nitrogen, sulfur, moisture and inert material in the fuel.
 

Below, we explain the physical meaning of each term:

— Carbon Contribution

Carbon is the main element responsible for the energy released in the combustion of fossil fuels and biomass. When fully oxidized, it forms carbon dioxide (CO₂), releasing heat. The coefficient 34,106 kJ/kg represents the average amount of energy released per unit mass of carbon in the fuel.

— Hydrogen Contribution

Hydrogen has the highest calorific value per unit mass of all combustible elements. When it oxidizes, it forms water vapor (H₂O), releasing a large amount of energy. However, part of this heat is deducted in the LHV calculation, since the water formed is considered to be in the vapor phase, without recovering the heat of condensation. The coefficient 90,962 kJ/kg already corresponds to the net value after deducting the effect of vaporizing the water produced.

— Effect of Oxygen

The oxygen present in the fuel does not contribute to energy release; on the contrary, it is already partially combined with carbon and hydrogen, reducing the available energy potential. Thus, the higher the oxygen content, the lower the LHV. The negative coefficient –8,449 kJ/kg represents this energy reduction.

— Nitrogen Contribution

Nitrogen, when present, oxidizes to NO, NO₂, NOx, releasing energy. Its effect is practically neutral because of the low nitrogen content compared with the other elements. The coefficient 5,941 kJ/kg indicates the energy released per unit mass of organic nitrogen present.

— Sulfur Contribution

Sulfur, when present, oxidizes to sulfur dioxide (SO₂), releasing energy. Its contribution is smaller than that of carbon and hydrogen, but still relevant in fossil fuels such as coal and fuel oil. The coefficient 9,373 kJ/kg indicates the energy released per unit mass of sulfur.

— Moisture Loss

Moisture (U) directly reduces the LHV, since the water in the fuel must be evaporated during combustion, consuming part of the energy released. The factor –2,512 kJ/kg corresponds to the average latent heat of vaporization of water, deducted from the useful energy available. Thus, the higher the moisture content, the lower the calorific value.

— Loss from mineral impurities

Minerals and soil are largely inert in calorific terms: they dilute the combustible content per unit mass and therefore reduce the LHV per kg of material received. Some minerals (e.g. carbonates such as CaCO₃) undergo endergonic decomposition that consumes heat (an additional penalty). In addition, some minerals can also retain bound water (water of crystallization) that requires energy to be removed. A more rigorous equation describing the effect of minerals in the fuel would take the following form.

In this equation , is the estimated energy needed for the thermal decomposition of CaCO₃. This term only appears if there are significant carbonates in the ash. Wb is the mass fraction of bound/crystalline water associated with minerals (if any) and Lb is the energy needed to release this bound water. To use these parameters, we would need a characterization of the mineral fraction of the ash produced in the boiler. So, for practical purposes, we will consider only the dilution effect on the fuel. In other words, to simplify the calculations the influence of mineral impurities on the fuel only reduces the fuel’s elemental composition.

LHV Results for Mill and Diffuser

To apply the LHV equation to bagasse, we will use the elemental composition of bagasse shown in Table 2

Table 2 – Elemental composition of sugarcane bagasse

Element

Bagasse fiber

(Dry basis)

Diffuser bagasse

Mill bagasse

C

47,91%

22,47%

23,38%

H

5,91%

2,77%

2,89%

N

0,33%

0,15%

0,16%

S

0,04%

0,02%

0,02%

O

48,8%

21,48%

22,35%

U

–

50 %

50 %

M

–

3,1 %

1,2 %

Applying the equation to calculate the LHV of bagasse, we obtain the following LHV values:

This methodology produced a result very similar to that found experimentally by Rein (2007), who determined that the LHV of diffuser bagasse is 7,200 kJ/kg, while that of mill bagasse was 7,497 kJ/kg.

 

 

Conclusion

The difference in LHV between mill and diffuser bagasse arises because most of the soil that enters with the cane ends up in the bagasse in the diffusion process. This article highlights the importance of considering bagasse composition in commercial negotiations, depending mainly on its application. Adopting technical criteria such as LHV can make the market fairer and more efficient, especially given the growing demand for energy biomass.

 

 

References

Van Loo, S., & Koppejan, J. (2008). The Handbook of Biomass Combustion and Co-firing. Earthscan.

Demirbaş, A. (2004). Estimating the Calorific Values of Lignocellulosic Fuels. Energy Exploration & Exploitation, 22(5), 135–143.

Demirbaş, A. (1997). Calculation of higher heating values of biomass fuels. Fuel, 76(5), 431–434.

ASTM D5865-19. Standard Test Method for Gross Calorific Value of Coal and Coke.

Rein, P. (2007). Cane Sugar Engineering.

Share article

LinkedIn
WhatsApp
Twitter